ShortlistHome

Methodology

How we pick, in plain language — and what we do not do.

What we are

Shortlist Home is a research-based buying guide. We do not run a lab and we do not do hands-on testing. We say so on every page, because a pick that was never tested should never be presented as if it was.

How a shortlist is built

  1. Shortlist the category. We gather the products buyers actually consider for one category, from manufacturer specs, retailer listings and public buyer feedback.
  2. Rank on verifiable facts. Specs that can be traced to a manufacturer or retailer source, public rating volume, and buyer mentions. A number we cannot source is left blank, never guessed.
  3. Four roles, four budgets. Top pick, upgrade, best value and premium. One of them fits most budgets; the rest cover the edges.
  4. Write the trade-offs. Every pick gets a “Skip if” and a trade-off. A recommendation without a downside is an ad, not advice.
  5. Check the price, show the date. Every price carries the date it was checked. Prices are re-checked on a schedule and after any merchant link change.

Multi-merchant comparison

Where a direct merchant price and an Amazon price both exist for the same product, both are shown. The direct merchant price often carries a higher commission for us; that never decides the ranking. Rankings are made before any commission is considered, and the same rule applies to every product.

What we never do

Prices and links

Prices change. A price shown here is the price on the date it was checked, and that date is printed next to it. If a merchant changes its store URL or tracking link, our link check flags it and the link is regenerated or removed — a dead link is worse than no link. Link checks run monthly, price checks run more often.

Corrections

If a price, spec or pick on this site is wrong, tell us through the contact page and we will fix it and note the correction.